Gruesome, Complex, and Hopeful
As a piece of narrative nonfiction, this book works well to explore the monstrous conditions prevalent in animal agriculture. As a piece of investigative journalism, not so much. There are too many asides that pertain to the author’s personal interactions and relationships with people in the industry, like the multiple men who wanted to date her. I assume she mentioned these things to say something deeper about the character of those working in the industry, but I could have done without them as they didn’t really seem pertinent to the theme of the book. The first part of the book was particularly difficult to get through, with its gruesome graphic depictions of the conditions of factory farms and slaughter houses. What I appreciate about this book is that Faruqi doesn’t merely expose and excoriate the industry and those who work in it, but that she searches for and proposes solutions instead of merely making this book about convincing everyone to go vegan. She also describes the complexity and contradictions of the people she encountered during her visits to farming sites. This book does fail in one major aspect, though: Faruqi throws out a lot of statistics but rarely cites sources. Given that she admittedly lied to so many in the industry (something she viewed as a lesser evil to the practices of the places), citing sources is crucial to lend credence to her tale. This shouldn’t be taken as me disbelieving what she cites; I just wanted her to have something more than her word to back up her stats. I agree with Faruqi’s offered solution and matrix regarding animal agriculture whole heartedly. One need not listen to the entire book, as the Conclusion contains the most important substance of her book. She itemizes and articles very sound principles that will improve not just the conditions of animals that we eat, but also those who work in the industry, our health, and the environment. I will say, though, she looked too quixotically at European nations as exemplary models to emulate. Also, I don’t know that I’d look to India as an example of successful food systems based on vegetarianism, not when so many of the Indian people are starving to death. At the conclusion of this book, I couldn’t help but wonder what she’d say after spending time in the produce agriculture, which is also rife with some very questionable practices. At any rate, our entire food system requires reform and Faruqi’s book is sure to bring awareness to the issues affecting our global and local systems. For a completely different look at the treatment of cattle by a truly pastoral society, I recommend listening to Anna Badkhen’s "Walking with Abe". For me, that audiobook reveals some of the holes in Faruqi’s pie-in-the-sky view of how we should look to other societies to create reform of cattle agriculture in the “civilized” world.

