Skip the Personal
I have serious reservations about rating this book highly. On the one hand, the language of the book is precise (read: lofty diction) and poetic. On the other, the language is perhaps too elevated given the simple living of the people and the places in which they live. That said, Badkhen uses her precise word choices in what feels like a natural way, i.e. no words stick out, they flow effortlessly, especially as read by Elisabeth Rodgers. What I find drags the book down is the author’s attempt to fuse her personal search for internal peace, to mend her broken heart from a failed romance, with the anthropological approach she’s taken in regards to the Fulani and the others she encounters during her year in the region. I had expected the book to present some aggrandized or noble view of the Fulani and their African neighbors, like the Bozo and Ba, this eternal quest that Western peoples like to engage upon to seek some lost secrets of living a better life or living more in synch with nature. Instead, thankfully, I got to see these peoples through a fairly objective lens. And the picture Badkhen paints is not so pretty or noble. It must have been an exceptional challenge not to make judgmental statements about the treatment of animals, children, women, and even the men themselves. I can’t help but wonder how she managed not to speak up. The Fulani elder Oumarou seemed convinced that milk will cure anyone if they are sick. In actuality, dairy products only exasperate illnesses. Or how about when she watched children torture and brutally kill an owlet because their superstitions say that owls kill children by sprinkling dust from a cemetery on them? That had to be painful to watch and do nothing about, but Badkhen maintains her reserve. So would I recommend this book? Yes, but only as long as you ignore the personal heartache components, which are actually sparse, and listen to it as anthropological nonfiction.

