Well-narrated but bleak
Bill Homewood gives a stirring reading of this bleak novel. His style of narration takes some getting used to, but if you give him a chance, you’ll find that his voice is beautifully expressive and at times downright lyrical. My problem is with the book itself. I read it out of a sense of duty, but I hated Julien Sorel, and I began to find his claustrophobic self-consciousness unbearable. I know many readers come to feel some sympathy for Julien by the end, but I’m not one of them. In a nutshell, Julien is a sociopath. Stendhal says, in so many words, that he “lacks any sense of fellow-feeling,” and Julien makes that clear repeatedly. He’s brilliant at Latin and memorization, and on that basis gets a job as a tutor. He forces himself to seduce Madame de Rênal, not because he really wants to but because it plays into his what-would-Napoleon-do ethic. Discovered and forced to flee at gunpoint, he does a stint at seminary, and then takes a position as private secretary to a Duke. But then the old thing commences again. This time he seduces the duke’s daughter Mathilde. She falls madly in love with him — partly as the result of his deliberate gamesmanship — and gets pregnant. Her father overcomes his rage to make a generous settlement on the couple. But in answer to his inquiries about Julien, he learns of the previous scandal from Madame de Rênal herself. The marriage plans are broken off and Julien is once again a fugitive. So what does he do? He goes back to his old town and shoots Madame de Rênal in the middle of a church service. She doesn’t die, but his attempt is enough to earn him the guillotine. As he sits in prison waiting for the sentence to be carried out, he is visited by both women. Madame de Rênal has forgiven him — and he decides he really does love her after all, and treats Mathilde, disgraced and pregnant with his child, with utter contempt. So no, no sympathy for Julien here. It’s a well-produced audiobook, but not one I’ll be returning to anytime soon.

