OK, so I was wrong…
There is no question that the works of P. G. Wodehouse should form a substantial part of your audio diet. Regular ingestion of The Master’s output will impart a healthy glow to one’s coat, give one a brighter, more enterprising eye and a decidedly springier step. With a very few exceptions (like The Coming of Bill) Wodehouse’s special brand of harmless humor is recommended by ten out of ten knowledgeable Harley Street medicos. So the question isn’t, “Should I purchase this volume of Wodehouse?” but rather, “Should I risk a segment of the hard-earned on this particular recording of Wodehouse?” That is the only question under advisement below. All clear? Good. Now we may proceed. I’ve savored Frederick Davidson. I’ve thoroughly enjoyed Jonathan Cecil. I’ve delighted in James Saxon, John Wells, Jeremy Sinden and Nigel Lambert. All have brought their peculiar vocal style to P. G. Wodehouse’s exquisite prose. Only once have I been truly disappointed, and that was when I tried Simon Vance’s reading of “Uneasy Money”. Flat, I thought. Uninspired. Davidson squeezed every nuance out of every syllable. Saxon lent an orotund mock-gravity. Nigel Lambert was engagingly goofy—especially in his performance of “Uneasy Money”, which I thoroughly enjoyed. But Simon Vance just…read the words. So when I saw that Downpour was releasing some new Wodehouse recordings, I was there with tons of good advice. I knew, of course, that Frederick Davidson was no longer with us, but surely James Saxon or Jonathan Cecil or the superb Mr. Sinden was available? I sent emails. I pounded tables. I haunted the lobby of the Downpour studios and organized petition drives and spontaneous flash mobs (calling ourselves, of course, “Occupy Downpour”.). Only to discover that all my candidates were, like the above, no longer among those present. Awkward. After the announcement of their demise, via megaphone, from the top-floor balcony of The Downpour Building in central Manhattan, my spontaneous flash mob and I didn’t know which way to look. Very soon after that, Downpour let us know that it was time to go home and leave the choice of voices to the professionals. After a small cash consideration (bus fare) we all did so. A few weeks later it was made known that Simon Vance was their choice. I grimaced. Yes. Mr. Vance was superb with James Bond thrillers, perfect when serving up The Portrait of Dorian Gray and spellbinding with the D’Artagnan saga. But when he does Wodehouse he just…reads the words. Still, I clicked on the “sample” for Quick Service and hoped for the best. And the more I listened, the more I realized that “just reading the words” was not such a bad thing to do when the words proceed from a craftsman like Sir Pelham. Yes, I miss the extra soupcon of comic inflection Jeremy Sinden lent to a description of a character’s state of mind, or the knowing wink Frederick Davidson gave as a friendly drink slowly degenerated into an unintentional debauch. But there is merit in Simon Vance’s approach, too. Of all the readers of Wodehouse I’ve encountered, he’s the one who most allows the writing to stand on it’s own. And this is writing that can do that very well. As for the owners of the cars that may have been overturned and/or burned during the "March to Make Jeremy Sinden the Reader for Quick Service", my solicitor will contact you.

