Taking Potshots and Missing
Maybe I’m being a little sensitive, but this book strikes me as an obvious knee-jerk reactionary rant against Gary Taubes and his book Good Calories, Bad Calories. Perhaps, it’s because Taubes’ points out all the errors that resulted from the loosely drawn conclusions taken from Campbell’s famous China Study. Having read Good Calories, Bad Calories, I know that Campbell got many of the things he asserts about Taubes’ findings wrong. In addition, he accuses Taubes of poor scientific rigor and of selling products. Anyone who has experienced Taubes’ book could say without doubt that Campbell’s assertion is flat-out wrong, as GC,BC was so scientifically rigorous that it reads like a trudge through thick mud. And as for selling product? No such thing. Campbell would be wise to note that he’s pointing his finger back at himself on both charges. Cambpell also seems to think that just because he has PhD tacked on to his name we should all accept what he says as truth without him having to back up his points with scientific rigor. One of the worst aspects of how this book is written is all the name calling, a sure sign of someone who is not confident in their own authority. The book is not completely without merit, but overall, it reads like so many of the other snake-oil salesman type medical books currently on the market. The most redeeming aspect of this audiobook is Don Hagen's narration. His handle on the copious medical and scientific terms is superb.

