What the…?
I think—and this is only a guess—but I think the main premise of this novel is that somewhere, somehow, there was a massive disconnect in man’s relationship with God. Now, in 1928, when The Bishop’s Wife was published, it’s gotten so bad that religious people think it their bounden duty to not enjoy sex, angels sent to provide divine guidance are instead all too human and do things like fall in love and kiss other men’s wives, and somehow angels—and, by extension, God Himself—are helpless to change “what man has made them”. All theology and philosophy just get in the way, spoiling the greater vision God had in mind for us—a vision that is never articulated but only mourned over because it’s so irretrievable. I don’t know when three hours ever seemed so long. The puerility of the premise—if indeed that is the premise of this muddled book—would be bad enough. The thin writing and wooden character development make things even worse. Stephen Thorne’s narration is as straightforward and un-nuanced as the words he’s reading, but then that may not be his fault. He had very little to work with here. Not that Nathan wasn’t on to some important things. Our pride in our technology, our buildings and prosperity are indeed things that threaten to replace God in our lives. The problem in Nathan’s vision (as far as I can understand it) is that the alternative—drawing closer to God—is impossible because of that now-unbridgeable gap that exists due to that undefined disconnect that happened sometime or other way back when. Maybe I’m completely wrong. Maybe I’m too perky. But I just can’t assent to the profound hopelessness that inhabits this book.

