Good but lacking essentials
Having just finished this work, I have to admit the detail was massive. I see Rockefeller and his legacy in a new light, thanks to Chernow's excellent research and appreciate what the entire family did to build our nation. Although many think of the man as a controlling monopolist, Chernow balances the scales with what he believes is a full account of his benevolence. The author's failure to credit Rockefeller with a business acumen consistent with his faith, fails the reader as to Rockefeller's true motive. Chernow seems almost befuddled by the fact that Rockefeller could justify, as a devout Christian, putting competition out of business. For Rockefeller, his self-interest closely corresponded with God's while most of his competitors were interested in quick cash, and a host of illicit uses for same. The Biblical businessman who sets out to earn millions for the purpose of giving it away to worthy causes has no problem "competing" with those without the same purpose. That competition invariably includes putting people out of business, which is the nature of true capitalism. Unfortunately Rockefeller could not insure the same Godly principles would be maintained by his underlings. Chernow failed to mention the numerous employees terminated for failing to maintain Rockefeller's principles and instead focused on what he perceived as hypocrisy. By focusing on his contemporary critics, who he admits ultimately failed to impress anyone except self-serving politicians, Chernow fails the reader. Rockefeller was biblically consistent in his personal life, although somewhat fundamental but considering the vast amounts given to charity and the tiny estate at his death, the branding of the man as a "vile monopolist" seems incredulous. The error modern historions who have little or no business/economic background make is the false understanding that competition is something designed to aid the consumer, which is the ultimate good. This latter day philosophy defies the Bible, which describes the investment of capital (True Capitalism) as something one does for his family, his church community and the world by benevolence rather than low prices. The fact that our government after the "Gilded Age" began to hamper business with laws designed to pander to voters doesn't make it right. Rockefeller understood this and unfortunately Chernow doesn't.

